Hunters fend off pack of aggressive Wolves…Really?
November 5, 2010
Two Flathead Valley men who were retrieving an elk in the South Fork Flathead drainage say they ended up fending off a pack of aggressive wolves Saturday.
They were forced to leave behind the elk, and they ended up killing one wolf, resulting in an investigation because wolves are still protected under the Endangered Species Act.
Mark Appleby, a 49-year-old hunter from Columbia Falls, shot the 6-point bull elk the day before, on Oct. 29, off the Deep Creek Road east of Hungry Horse Reservoir. He quartered the animal and hiked out with the head with the intent of returning to pack out the meat with horses the next day.
Whitefish resident Raymond Pitman, 27, volunteered to help. The two men held a press conference Thursday in Kalispell to tell their story, with legislators and several reporters attending.
They rode in about two about two hours from their truck and carefully approached the downed elk, knowing there could be bears or wolves in the area. There was only a coyote track, so they had lunch and started rigging the horses up to pack out the meat.
After they had been in the area for about an hour, the horses started to spook, their attention focused on a nearby hillside.
“The horses started freaking out,” said Pitman, who first saw a group of wolves approaching no more than 30 to 40 yards away. Appleby saw them soon after.
“There were seven or eight of them and they were running at us at full stride at first,” said Appleby, who dashed toward the wolves to get his rifle.
“I was about halfway there and I heard Raymond shoot with his .44 mag,” Appleby wrote in his statement to Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks. “When I reached my gun, I picked it up and the wolves stopped. I pointed my gun at them at about the same time they started to run at us again. At that time, I feared for my life and the horses and my friend and I started to shoot.”
Appleby fired several rounds at the wolves, which then retreated back up the timbered hillside.
“On this one, there was no time to think,” said Appleby, who is convinced that his friend’s pistol bought him the time to get to his rifle. “If he didn’t have that .44 on his side, we wouldn’t be talking to you.”
But the wolves did not fully retreat, Pitman said.
One started howling, and the others joined in. The horses continued to panic, and were literally leading Appleby and Pitman away from the area.
“It was a mess, an absolute mess,” said Appleby, adding that his stirred-up horse was beating him up as he tried to control it.
The wolves continued to push the two men and their horses, pursuing but staying mostly out of sight.
“I’m getting mad talking about it,” said Appleby, who was in disbelief that he was forced to abandon his meat. “I said I can’t believe we’re hauling the horses out empty.”
“The only reason they quit following us is that I was shooting at them,” Pitman said.
Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks Warden Perry Brown returned to the site with Appleby and Pitman on Monday, and determined that the wolves had followed the group for about 200 yards away from the elk.
“Perry went back with them and he found a dead wolf and multiple tracks at the site that indicated wolves had been present,” said Jim Satterfield, Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks regional supervisor.
The elk meat had been fed on by wolves that are believed to be part of the Firefighter Pack, and at some point, a grizzly bear got in on the kill and buried the remains. Brown would not approach the dirt mound out of concern that the bear was still in the immediate area.
Satterfield said Brown’s report was turned over to a U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service investigator.
“The ball is in their court right now,” he said. “It would be the same thing as if someone shot a grizzly bear.”
Appleby said he was interviewed by a federal official from Great Falls.
“He said if the game warden said it was self-defense … it would probably be the end of it,” said Appleby, who is more concerned about what an inexperienced hunter or unarmed person could do in the same situation.
“It was a scary situation, that’s for sure,” Appleby said.
It was not the first time a hunter has been intimidated by wolves.
Last year, an animal warden with the Flathead County Sheriff’s Office shot an elk in the Darby area and had to hike around a ravine reach his kill. By the time he got there, wolves were already on the elk, and he feared approaching them.
State Sen. Bruce Tutvedt, R-Kalispell, is concerned that there could be more incidents in the future.
“This is a horrible situation, but our hands are tied,” said Tutvedt, who attended the press conference that was organized by former Flathead County Commissioner Gary Hall, a friend of Appleby’s.
Tutvedt believes the best remedy is congressional action that would delist wolves in the Northern Rockies and restore the state of Montana’s authority to manage wolves with a legal hunt.
Fred Hodgeboom, president of Montanans for Multiple Use, also attended the gathering, announcing that the group has started a Web site (http://www.wolfclash.com) for the public to post reports about encounters with wolves.
Wolfwatcher follow up to this story…
These hunters kill an elk and take the head. Trophy hunt. If they have ever hunted before they would know that returning a day later to the carcass they should expect to find scavengers. Perhaps that is exactly why they did wait a day! What they did by killing a wolf in this manner is totally illegal under the ESA. They have come up with a much more elaborated story now after thinking of what the consequences could be as a result of their illegal actions. Both “hunters” should be charged. People can speak out in their support because of the sheer fact that they have a hatred for wolves, and that is too bad. If this was a case where wolves attacked livestock or someones pet and they had no other choice but to shoot I would not have a problem with it. But once you really think about what happened there is no doubt that this resulted in an illegal killing of an animal protected under the Endangered Species Act. .plain and simple.
The only time that wolves might act aggressively would be if a competitor was trying to take their food source, in this case the carcass. I have been in the immediate area of wolves on several carcasses and have never felt threatened. Wolves take all precautions to avoid humans in fact. This behavior by these two hunters is outrageous but condoned by groups such as wolfclash listed above. Take action here and let your voices be heard so this doesn’t set a precedent in the hunting world. This action is nothing more than baiting wolves in and killing them, and is against the law!